Castle: Secret Santa (2012)
Now, there was also plenty of charm in this episode, particularly at the beginning. Castle and Beckett investigate a dead man in a Santa suit who, predictably, fell mysteriously out of the sky. The case is interesting, and the banter is fun, but all the little sad subplots about the various characters got a bit tedious. Not every named character needs angst!
Plus, I am really tired of Beckett having only the one character trait for every occasion. (Best line of the night: after Beckett explained how the long-ago death of her mother keeps her from enjoying Christmas, Erin leaned over to me and whispered “So she became...a BAT.”)
All of that said, I did still enjoy watching this. I don’t know how much fun it is in total for someone who isn’t familiar with the show, but Erin seemed to really enjoy the first half or so, although by the end he was rolling his eyes a bit.
Castle is a quirky cop drama, fundamentally, and you have to embrace that if you’re going to enjoy it. It’s formulaic, and this episode tries to be a little more emotionally heavy than I think the cast really pulls off, but it’s a decent holiday treat overall.