The Roaring Twenties (1939)
I'd apologize for the spoiler, but let's be honest: this is a gangster movie produced under the Motion Picture Code, which prohibited criminals from getting a happy ending. The genre and production date are spoilers. Still, if you don't want more of the story spoiled, feel free to close your browser window in another paragraph.
You should know that this one's worth seeing, assuming you're not adverse to movies from this era. The Roaring Twenties stands out from the crowd of early gangster movies (or at least the ones I've seen) thanks to notably well-developed characters. The movie's antagonist is a bit two-dimensional, but even he's played by Humphrey Bogart and therefore charming. Most of the other characters are rounded, interesting people, none more so than the movie's lead, Eddie, played by gangster movie veteran, James Cagney. Eddie isn't dumb or cruel; he's capable of violence but rarely chooses it. The movie is built around the idea that most criminals aren't sociopaths or monsters but rather people who find themselves seeking easy solutions to difficult problems.
Eddie is also unsurprisingly a sort of symbol of a bygone era. As the movie's title suggests, this a story about an period of time, and there's a sense that Eddie represents that period. The movie is framed as a cautionary tale, but it doesn't really even try to hide the nostalgia.
The story kicks off in the trenches of the war, with three soldiers - Cagney's Eddie, Bogart's George, and Lloyd (Jeffrey Lynn) meeting and starting a sort of friendship (or at least acquaintanceship). It becomes clear pretty quickly they have very different codes, with George lacking mercy or compassion, Lloyd being the most gentle, and Eddie falling in the middle. The war ends, the three head back to America, and we lose touch with George for a while.
Eddie tries restarting his old life, but he discovers his prospects of finding decent work are few and far between. Eventually he finds himself arrested as a courier carrying alcohol during prohibition (he wasn't even aware what he had). He manages to get Panama Smith (Gladys George), the woman he was delivering to, off the hook, and she returns the favor by bailing him out and helping him find more lucrative work in the underworld. It quickly becomes apparent she's infatuated with Eddie, but he falls in love with a singer, Jean (Priscilla Lane), who was his pen pal during the war. In an effort to win Jean, Eddie becomes a major dealer in alcohol. He enlists the help of Lloyd, who by this point is a lawyer.
Eventually, he runs into George again, and the two form a partnership. Unfortunately for Eddie, George is still driven by his more violent impulses: during a robbery, he murders a couple police. Lloyd, explaining that a line has been crossed, walks away from the organization, and Jean goes with him.
Eddie is distraught but able to hold his criminal empire together... at least until the stock market crash of 1929. George is in far better shape, but he shows Eddie no more compassion than he showed anyone else.
The movie jumps ahead a few years to 1933, and we find Eddie is driving a cab, while George is a minor crime lord. At this point, Eddie runs into Jean and Lloyd, now married with a young child. Lloyd is working in the DA's office, a risky profession, given how much he knows about George and what George is willing to do to keep him from talking. Eddie tries to convince Lloyd to drop the case, but Lloyd is still devoted to his code. After some of George's men threaten Jean, she goes to Eddie for help on New Year's Eve. He initially refuses but eventually goes to confront George, anyway. That goes about as well as you'd expect, with Eddie shooting George and most of his gang but mortally wounded and dying on the steps of a church with Panama Smith left to mourn him.
The movie works mainly because Eddie is flawed but ultimately sympathetic. His turn to a life of crime feels natural, logical under the circumstances, and morally excusable. Hell, the movie frames his initial actions as far more morally sound than those of a society failing to offer better options to veterans. And, at least at first, there's an adventurous swashbuckling undercurrent to the enterprise, though that doesn't last. And some of what goes wrong is Eddie's fault: he's not overly violent, but he certainly uses his position to bully and manipulate others. He allows his ambition and goals to cloud his judgement, and as a result loses everything. The fact his failings feel like extensions of his character is a credit to the movie's script and Cagney's acting.
The movie also features some extremely cool narrative transitions that set the tone while providing historical context. Some of these are quite funny (there's a good amount of humor in this throughout, in fact), while others employ expressionistic imagery. My favorite of these involves a quick shot of a melting building to convey the sense of the world deteriorating at the start of the depression. It's an incredibly cool effect, one of many, in fact.
I would have liked the women to receive more depth - the script doesn't develop their characters to the same degree as some of the men - but they're not treated as stupid or simplistic, either. Lane gets some good musical numbers (which help set the pace and tone for the movie), and Gladys George gets some great moments, particularly near the end, but a little more focus on them would have made an already extremely strong movie all the more powerful.
I should note that Raoul Walsh's direction is a big part of why this works, though he's someone who should probably be looked at sideways - Walsh had a part in and was an assistant director for Birth of a Nation, which raises more than a few questions about his character.
The holiday elements may be brief, but they're certainly striking. Eddie initially meets up with Jean again right before Christmas, when he drives her home and briefly meets her child. While he's fallen on hard times, he realizes that Jean and Lloyd are thriving, though he also knows Lloyd is endangering that by going after George. Before things turn violent, George points out Eddie should be happy that he's planning to kill Lloyd, as that would give him another chance with Jean. Only Eddie knows that ship has sailed. More than that, he can see that Lloyd is a better man than he is, which may be part of the reason he's ultimately willing to sacrifice his own life for him and Jean.
This is, of course, mirroring the idea of the old year dying and making way for the new. In this case, it's not just a year, but an era. The Roaring Twenties, Prohibition, gangsters flaunting the law... all of it is a relic of a time that was exciting but irresponsible. Eddie is a symbol of that time, and his sacrifice is an acknowledgment of his responsibility to stand aside for a new time. The end is tragic but also hopeful.
You could draw parallels here with James Frazer, though I doubt that was the reference the movie was aiming for. Despite the sacrifice, this feels much more in line with traditional narratives surrounding the changing of the year, particularly in light of the various transition segments priming the viewer to think in terms of the progression of time.
Either way, New Year's makes for a powerful backdrop that accentuates the movie's themes and amplifies the pathos. It's an effective movie with complex characters, a great setting, and meticulous control of tone balancing humor, tragedy, and the sheer absurdity of the era. This one's absolutely worth checking out, particularly if you have any kind of an interest in classic gangster movies. But even if you don't, this might be good enough to win you over.
.jpg)
Comments
Post a Comment