All That Heaven Allows (1955)
The movie's mostly centered around Wyman's character, an aging widow named Cary, who falls in love with her gardener, Ron (Hudson), who feels the same way. However, they're separated by class and age (Wyman is eight years older than Hudson, with the movie suggesting their characters' age difference may be a bit wider). Eventually Ron proposes, and the movie's drama comes from Cary's struggles between her heart and societal expectations, most notably those surrounding her two children, both of whom are young adults vehemently opposed to the idea.
The movie openly challenges American social norms and conformity, as well as ideas surrounding what women are assumed to want as they age. There are relatively subtle themes of sex-positivity, feminism, and anti-capitalism running through the narrative. The movie presents the hypocrisy of older men attempting to take advantage of Cary while mocking her choice to be in a consenting relationship with a younger man. It explores the expectations society places on women (particularly widows), comparing present day America with ancient Egypt. And, perhaps most subversive for the era, it dismisses the importance of wealth as a motive for living, all but challenging capitalism. That theme wasn't uncommon a few decades earlier (both versions of Holiday explored similar ideas with a male love interest similar to Ron), but this was treading on dangerous ground for something released in the midst of the Hollywood blacklist. I suspect it skirted the issue by leaving just enough ambiguity surrounding which aspects of the wealthy businessmen were being critiqued, but the implication that a life spent in pursuit of money is empty compared with Ron's Thoreau-inspired ideology comes through pretty clear. Likewise, contrasting parties where we see Ron's blue-collar immigrant friends elevated above snobbish, gossiping wealthy socialites make for a striking political statement.
All of this works, thanks to Peg Fenwick's script and the cast's (mainly Wyman's) delivery. The jokes have enough bite to convey weight while remaining clever and genuinely funny. When this aims for comedy, it's good stuff. The problem, at least for those of us watching this decades later, is that the movie is ultimately a melodrama, not a romantic comedy. Or a horror, for that matter, though there's actually a moment during the Christmas sequence the movie could have ended effectively on that note. And as a melodrama... well... it's hard to rate, because the form itself feels antiquated. If you dig through the archive of reviews on this site, you'll find several reviews of melodrama I wrote before I had a handle on the genre. Now, I feel like I've seen enough to understand the genre, but excluding a handful of exceptions, I generally run into the issue I expect a lot of viewers will: this isn't an approach to storytelling that feels natural anymore. Again, that's a reflection of how storytelling conventions have changed; it doesn't imply any are better or worst. Still, if you're watching in 2026, you're going to be taken aback by how blunt the dramatic moments are and how directly the movie will lay out its morals (or at least the morals it's allowed to say out loud). There's a scene towards the end where a doctor just sort of reiterates Cary's conundrum and outright tells her what the right thing to do is, as if the filmmakers are speaking through him. These ideas have already been conveyed through natural dialogue and the story itself, but they're repeated in a sort of summary form. That's just not how we're taught structure and narrative are supposed to work in film anymore.
Then, because it's melodrama, things veer into even weirder territory. Cary attempts to go to Ron but doesn't find the courage to knock on his door. If she had, nothing would have played out differently, because he wasn't home. He was, however, close enough to see her from the top of a nearby cliff. He attempts to get her attention but instead manages to topple over, injuring himself. When Cary later finds out, she rushes to his side and vows to remain there.
It's bizarre. The sequence feels like it's here to punish the characters, but they haven't really done anything wrong. Likewise, Cary's resolution isn't a twist - she already decided she wanted to be with Ron, society be damned. The whole thing comes across as a series of random events designed to make the ending as dramatic as possible while still permitting a (mostly) happy ending. I can't weigh in on how well that worked in 1955, but seven decades later, it's kind of silly, even before the movie closes with a deer walking in front of the picturesque winter scene.
At the same time, the intervening time has added subtext surrounding Hudson's character. In the movie, he's proudly individualistic, willing to flaunt society's judgement surrounding who he loves and how he lives his life. In reality, Hudson didn't have the luxury of Ron's philosophy: as a gay man, Hudson would have faced far more scrutiny if details of his private life were public. But it's hard to watch this now without wondering if Hudson was conscious of the way his character's situation mirrored his own, and if perhaps some of his own thoughts were coming through in his delivery of Ron's indictment of society.
Though probably not all of his thoughts. Rock Hudson's politics skewed far more to the right than the movie's, despite his sexuality. He was a conservative Republican and was friends with Ronald Reagan prior to Hudson's AIDS diagnosis. He's not the only one in the movie with a connection to Reagan. Jane Wyman's third husband was the future president, and as such she became the first woman who could say a sitting president was her ex-husband.
But enough history - let's talk Christmas. As I said upfront, calling this a "Christmas movie" might be a bit of a stretch. The holidays themselves only take up a brief portion of the runtime, most notably a scene where Cary's semi-adult children return for Christmas. At this point in the movie, she'd already broken off her engagement with Ron due to their reaction to the idea she'd be marrying a younger man and selling the family house. When they come home, she learns her daughter has gotten engaged and her son is planning on leaving, as well. After insisting she sacrifice her own future for theirs, they announce their futures don't include her. Her son even floats the idea of selling the family house. But all's not entirely lost: they've gotten her something to keep her company... a television (which, if they'd known her, they'd have realized she didn't want). The camera zooms into the screen as she's told it will give her all the company she needs, and of course all we see is her reflection. Again, the movie could have finished here as a sort of pseudo-horror story about a woman destroyed by society.
There's a little more Christmas than this, including an earlier scene where Cary encounters Ron while shopping for a tree and mistakes a friend for a new lover, but the most memorable moment is with her children (who, it should be noted, are portrayed as real shits). The TV bit also echoes an idea from early in the movie, where it's suggested that American widows experience a fate analogous to wives in Egypt entombed with their husbands (I know that's not quite right, but let's give them a pass on historical accuracy). The image of Cary's reflection boxed in the television (along with similar imagery in scenes in this section) reflect that idea effectively and give the moment a gravitas that's missing from the more exaggerated finale.
But it's also worth exploring the holidays and winter as a symbol of age. Cary has, at least from the perspective of her friends and family, already lived her life. As such, she's expected to diminish into an eternally mourning old maid. In that respect, the time of year reflects both outside assumptions and her own fears. She isn't ready to simply be an "old woman." She still desires life, love, and sex (that last one is more implied than stated, but it's pretty clear that's in the mix). In this respect, the season is either a symbolic end, as in The Lion in Winter, or period to be endured. My interpretation of the deer at the end is of a symbol of the coming spring, suggesting there are many more seasons in front of her.
Overall, it's an interesting film that holds up well thematically... at least for the most part (the feminist elements are somewhat undermined by chauvinistic assumptions, such as Ron's unwillingness to compromise to be with her being a merit, while her reluctance to accept social consequences of being with him being a flaw). But overall, it pretty clearly skews to the left, which is unusual for the era. The jokes are also funny, though that's of course only significant for the parts that have jokes. Likewise, the direction is effective, and the cinematography is striking. It's all well done, including the dramatic twists, but whether that's enough to make up for those sections' dated style is going to come down to personal preferences.
.jpg)
Comments
Post a Comment