Little Caesar (1931)

This isn't a Christmas movie and only includes roughly ten minutes set around the holidays (New Year's Eve, specifically), but the film is important enough as a piece of Hollywood history to be worth discussing, if only to highlight how themes and ideas associated with the season were being used in virtually identical ways in the early days of talkies to how they appear now. Little Caesar was directed by the extremely prolific Mervyn LeRoy, who - among numerous other famous projects - directed the 1949 adaptation of Little Women and produced The Wizard of Oz. In terms of holiday connections, this also features Glenda Farrell in a significant role - longtime readers will know I'm a huge fan of the 1933 New Year's horror film, Mystery of the Wax Museum, in which she played a sort of proto-Lois Lane.

But Little Caesar's real claim to fame is it's one of two movies released in 1931 primarily credited with defining the concept of the mob or gangster movie as a genre (the other being The Public Enemy). Both movies are presented as morality stories about criminals trying to make it big and eventually dying, though it's likely the films' brutal violence that made them successful. These are considered extremely influential films, and if you have any sort of interest in the genre's history... well, you don't need my recommendation: you've already seen them.

The titular Little Caesar in the title is Rico (Edward G. Robinson), a smalltime criminal who moves east along with his best friend, Joe (Douglas Fairbanks Jr.). Rico dreams of a life as a crime lord, while Joe wants to leave that life behind and become a dancer. Their conflicting goals form the central backbone of the film. Rico's intellect, ambition, and fearlessness fuel his ascension through the underworld ranks. But what goes up, must come down: his fall is ultimately brought about by his friendship with (or perhaps love of) Joe, who he refuses to kill, even when Joe is about to go to the police. It's the one humane thing Rico does in the movie, the one moment of kindness and mercy, and he ultimately pays for it with his life.

I'm making it sound a lot more dramatic than it is in practice. Robinson plays Rico mostly two-dimensionally, with an exaggerated accent that would go on to become something of cliche in mafia movies. Aside from the one moment he refuses to kill his friend, he doesn't show much depth or emotion beyond annoyance, anger, and arrogance. Well rounded antiheroes would be added to the genre later: at this point, it's less tragedy than cautionary tale.

Where the movie does display complexity is in the cinematography and staging. I lost track of the number of times I found myself thinking, "that's where that shot was from," during the movie. This is one of those films that's been referenced and homaged countless times over the decades (soon to be a full century).

Again, if you're interested in film history in general - and even more if you're interested in mob movie history in particular - this isn't something I need to tell you about. This thing is a foundation of the genre, one of those movies still studied and respected. If you're just a fan of crime movies and the like, things become more complicated. On one hand, there's a lot to be appreciated in watching this as a piece of history, if you enjoy that sort of thing. But if that sounds like work, then you're probably better off with later installments in the genre.

As far as the holiday elements are concerned, the sequence plays out at the end of what I'll anachronistically refer to as Act I. Rico has joined a gang in the city and proven himself as a reliable crook. Joe, on the other hand, has found some success as a dancer and fallen in love with Olga (Farrell). He wants out, which Rico has told him is impossible. In fact, Rico commands him to assist in a robbery of the club where Joe works on New Year's Eve and makes it clear he doesn't have a choice. Things take a turn when the city's crime commissioner is coincidentally present and winds up murdered by Rico while Joe watches in horror before returning to Olga.

The movie doesn't dwell on the significance of the holiday, but the symbolism is pretty clear. This is a moment of transition, the beginning of Rico's rise and the point at which Joe resolves to walk away, even if it'll take him the rest of the movie to succeed. New Year's, of course, is a time of transformation from one period into another, and we see that line of delineation for both characters.

But, again, it's only ten or so minutes of an eighty minute movie. This isn't a holiday movie in itself, though I felt the extended sequence warranted inclusion here, given the movie's significance.

Comments