Old Acquaintance (1943)
Whether that's enough to justify calling this a New Year's movie is open to debate. On one hand, the song has become closely associated with the holiday, to the point it's become the single most iconic New Year's song. Its ties to New Year's aren't new, either - it was certainly connected to the holiday in the 1940s when this was made.
However, Auld Lang Syne isn't just a New Year's song, nor is it only used in that context. It can be viewed as a song about the passage of time, nostalgia, connections to vanishing past, and so on - all themes traditionally associated with New Year's and the Christmas season, to be sure, but not exclusive to them. The movie certainly had opportunities to establish a holiday setting and repeatedly declined to do so, which shouldn't be ignored. Though it's also worth noting both the 1943 film and the 1940 play it was based on premiered in time for the holiday season on their respective years. There's a case this qualifies as holiday media, but it's absolutely a tenuous one.
However there's another factor that tips the balance on whether or not it qualifies for discussion here: I just... I really like this, it's weird and fun, and I just really wanted to write about it. I mean, I also think the thematic and musical connections deliver what a lot of people are looking for in a New Year's film, and those themes are interesting to discuss in that context, but let's be clear: there's a bias here.
And that brings us to what this movie is, or perhaps more importantly what I think it isn't. Because the summary on Wikipedia and other locations I've seen present it as a drama, which...
Okay, it's not not a drama, but it is also kind of not a drama, if that makes sense. On second thought, even I can tell that doesn't make sense, so let me explain: Old Acquaintances is, by most definitions, a drama (or arguably a melodrama) following two women who are old friends growing older and struggling as their relationships (both with each other and others) are fraying at the edges. It's a story of heart ache, lost and unrequited love, and regret, along with jealousy, inadequacy, and the ephemeral nature of success and happiness.
It's also goddamn hilarious, because - and this is what makes the movie special - the point-of-view character is smart enough to see the patterns playing out around her. She understands why people do the things they do and what the costs are of living honorably and loving others. She essentially intuits that she's living in a melodrama and has developed a sardonic sense of humor about the world she's in.
And every other character is a complete idiot.
The result of this is something that feels like a parody of serious drama. I'm not entirely certain that was the goal here (though I think it's at least a strong possibility). The movie does seem to be trying to sell the emotion as genuine, so there's a chance some of the comedy is unintentional. If so, that only adds to the charm, and - just to be clear - most of the comedy is unambiguously meant to land as a joke. It's just a question whether this is a dramedy that's sort of aged into reading as a farce, or if it was really always meant as a comedy.
The fact it's based on a play complicates the issue. Without having read or seen the original, I'm relying on the Wikipedia summary, but at the very least it's structured very differently. The film expands the timeline from a month to roughly twenty years, giving them the freedom of showing rather than telling the backstory. This also means leads Bette Davis and Miriam Hopkins get to play their characters as they age. The makeup isn't all that convincing, but the two actresses make it work (unsurprising, given they're both Hollywood legends).
Davis plays the movie's protagonist and point-of-view character, Kit Marlowe (subtle!), a critically respected writer who's never married or had children. Hopkins plays Millie, her best friend from childhood, who begins the movie married and with a child on the way. Jealous of Kit's success, Millie takes up writing and quickly finds popular success as a romance author. By the time we jump ahead from the 1920s to the 1930s, she's well established and financially secure... but her home life has taken a hit. Her relationship with her husband is strained, and her daughter seems to like Kit better than her.
It's understandable. In most respects, Millie is unlikeable - she's bossy, conceited, short-tempered, and not particularly bright - but Kit has genuine affection for her. This becomes an issue when she develops feelings for Millie's husband, Preston (John Loder), who is in turn as infatuated with Kit as he's fed up with his wife. He eventually leaves Millie, but - despite her feelings - Kit is unwilling to betray her friend, or even consider it.
We jump ahead another decade to the 1940s and find Kit in a relationship with a younger man eager to marry her. She's initially reluctant due to the age difference and puts off giving him an answer a bit too long. By the time she decides she loves him, he's fallen for Deirdre (Dolores Moran), Millie's daughter. Meanwhile, Millie learns her ex-husband (who's getting remarried to a different woman) and Kit were in love when he left her and jumps to conclusions, escalating in a showdown that - like damn near everything in this movie - is delightfully ridiculous. Kit eventually puts everything right (or as right as can be expected), setting aside her heartbreak in order to ensure Deirdre ends up with the man of her dreams, even if that means Kit winds up alone. Or not entirely alone, as Millie comes to her senses and the two end the movie together as friends again.
Come to think of it, there should probably be an asterisk on the word, "friends." Saying that the women (Kit in particular) are coded as queer might be an understatement. Old Acquaintance is of course penned in by the Hays Code, but the subtext is hard to miss. On that reading the two women ending up together makes for a happy-ever-after, with their mourning about not ending up married coming off as even more perfunctory than it already did. The movie goes through the motions of upholding the usual sexist moralism of the time, telling us in one way or another that women engaging in sexual relationships outside of marriage and/or pursuing professional careers leads to divorce and misery, but that's not what it's showing us. The script can have Bette Davis's character in tears as she removes obstacles between the man she'd planned to marry and her friend's daughter, but whatever message it's pretending to convey is drowned out by the reality that her character seems to be the coolest, smartest person on the planet. Cautionary tales don't work if the audience wants to be like your tragic character, and I find it hard to believe director Vincent Sherman, Bette Davis, and pretty much everyone else involved with the project weren't in on the joke.
Regardless, watching her effortlessly navigate the genre's tropes is a blast, as is seeing her and Hopkins play what feel like alternate universe versions of the leads from Wicked. Watching this you can tell a lot what makes this work is stuff that aged fortunately, while other aspects were always good. And honestly I quickly found I didn't care how much was one or the other. Either way, the movie's a lot of fun.
.jpg)
Comments
Post a Comment